As entertainment-world editors, we spend all day looking at pictures of our favorite celebrities in designer footwear, and [expletive] if we aren’t jealous.

But we recently discovered we don’t have to be, thanks to an insanely affordable fashion-subscription site that has become our new obsession: ShoeDazzle. We were skeptical at first. How can they deliver every trend we see on stars’ tootsies — from sexy stiletto sandals  to feminine ballet flats, and quirky menswear-inspired oxfords — for $40 a month instead of sky-high designer prices? There had to be a catch, and there was only one way to find out what it was: Test the product, and we found that ShoeDazzle really makes shoes the centerpiece of your look.

Today, millions of women get their personalized fashion fix from them, with access to top trends, style inspiration, and world-class service.

So we had editors try out ShoeDazzle’s latest winter looks which they thought could go from day to night (we’re in NYC, people — not a ton of room in our closets) and wore them over the course of a week. The verdict: The boots are keepers, ShoeDazzle is for real. Here are our three favorite styles. Oh, and one added bonus that will really widen your eyes — All new VIP members can take advantage of an exclusive Buy 1 Get 1 Free offer! So feed your shoe obsession today.