Rachel Uchitel may have once cast her spell on famous men like Tiger Woods, but the infamous mistress recently struck out with one high-profile bachelor: Jake Pavelka.

A source revealed to Breaking Celebrity News exclusively that Uchitel sent one of Pavelka’s closest friends an email asking to be set up with the newly-single former pilot.

Jake recently parted ways with Vienna Girardi, his final pick as ABC’s Bachelor, ending their engagement in a public mudslinging match complete with allegations of infidelity, lies, and questions about Jake’s sexual orientation. The couple has not spoken since the heated taping of their televised reunion on June 24.